The Strategy Was Brilliant. Unfortunately, Nobody Told the Organisation!

Why organisations struggle to turn strategic ambition into operational reality and what effective leaders do differently.

The strategy presentation was magnificent.

 

There were elegant graphics, carefully selected photographs of mountains, an inspirational quotation and a compelling diagram featuring several interconnected circles. The organisation's future had never looked more promising.

 

The executive team applauded. The CEO thanked everyone for their contribution. The presentation was circulated, the strategy was launched and the organisation returned to doing almost exactly what it had been doing before.

 

Six months later, the leadership team commissioned a review to establish why the strategy hadn't gained sufficient traction. The possibility that the strategy had never meaningfully left the boardroom was not considered until slide 47.

 

The difference between having a strategy and being strategic

Most organisations understand the importance of strategy. Considerable time, energy and money are invested in developing strategic plans, identifying opportunities and articulating ambitions. The resulting documents can be impressive, thoughtful and entirely convincing. The difficulty begins when the organisation is expected to do something differently.

 

A strategy should help people make choices about where to concentrate resources, which opportunities to pursue and, importantly, what not to do. Yet some strategic plans appear to have been designed primarily to avoid making those choices. Everything is important, every department has a strategic priority and every existing initiative has somehow acquired a new strategic justification.

 

In his influential 1996 Harvard Business Review article, What Is Strategy?, Michael Porter emphasised the importance of trade-offs and the distinctive choices that underpin competitive strategy. His argument remains relevant: strategy involves deciding what an organisation will not do, as well as what it will.

 

If everything is a strategic priority, the organisation hasn't established its priorities. It has produced a comprehensive list of its aspirations.

 

The strategy has been communicated. Apparently.

Once the strategy is approved, the next challenge is communication. This typically involves a leadership conference, a company-wide presentation and an email from the CEO explaining how excited everyone should be about the journey ahead. There is nothing inherently wrong with any of this. The problem is assuming that communicating a strategy is the same as creating a shared understanding of it.

 

Imagine an organisation whose new strategic ambition is to become more customer centric. The Sales Director interprets this as providing greater flexibility to customers. Operations interpret it as improving consistency. Finance understands it to mean increasing customer profitability. Meanwhile, employees are wondering whether they are still expected to answer every customer enquiry within three minutes.

 

Everyone has heard the strategy. The challenge is they have heard different versions of disparate strategies.

 

Research by Donald Sull, Charles Sull and Rebecca Homkes, published in Harvard Business Review in 2015, examined common assumptions about strategy execution. Their findings highlighted challenges including coordination across organisational boundaries and the gap between communicating strategic objectives and ensuring managers understand them.

 

The lesson is important. A strategy isn't successfully communicated when everyone has received the presentation. It's successfully communicated when people understand how it should influence their thinking and behaviour.

 

The organisational equivalent of adding another suitcase

One of the more curious features of strategic planning is the apparent assumption that organisations possess an unlimited capacity for additional work.

 

A new strategy is introduced, accompanied by ambitious initiatives, transformation programmes and revised objectives. Existing responsibilities remain largely unchanged. Employees are encouraged to embrace the opportunities ahead while continuing to deliver everything they were already delivering. It's rather like packing for a fortnight's holiday, discovering the suitcase is full and resolving the problem by adding another suitcase to the same suitcase.

 

The organisation may genuinely need to change. But strategic execution requires decisions about capacity, resources and competing commitments. Leaders who introduce new priorities without removing existing ones risk creating overload rather than progress.

 

The result can be a business in which employees attend meetings about strategic transformation during the time they previously spent doing the work that needs transforming. When progress slows, the leadership team may conclude that the organisation is resistant to change. Sometimes it is. Sometimes it is simply too busy.

 

What gets measured gets managed. Occasionally, it gets distorted.

Strategic objectives are often translated into performance indicators. This makes sense: leaders need to understand whether their decisions are producing the intended results. But measures can also become substitutes for the outcomes they were intended to represent.

 

Consider an organisation committed to improving customer service. It introduces targets for response times, call duration and the number of enquiries resolved. Employees become increasingly efficient at meeting those targets, while customers discover that their problems are being addressed more quickly but not necessarily more effectively. The dashboard is green. The customers are less enthusiastic.

 

In their 1992 article introducing the balanced scorecard, Robert Kaplan and David Norton argued for assessing organisational performance through multiple perspectives rather than relying exclusively on financial measures. The broader principle is useful here: performance measures should help leaders understand whether their strategy is working, not merely provide reassurance that activity is taking place.

 

A successful strategy should improve the organisation's performance, not just the appearance of its performance report.

 

Five actions leaders can take to turn strategy into reality

The good news is that effective strategic execution doesn't necessarily require another framework. It requires disciplined leadership.

 

  • First, make genuine choices. Establish a manageable number of strategic priorities and identify what the organisation will stop, reduce or postpone to create the capacity to deliver them.

  • Second, translate ambition into decisions. Help managers understand what the strategy means for resource allocation, customer relationships, operational priorities and everyday trade-offs.

  • Third, connect the organisation horizontally. Ensure departments understand how their contributions fit together. A strategy cannot be delivered effectively if each function interprets success independently.

  • Fourth, measure outcomes rather than activity alone. Review whether initiatives are producing the intended improvements, and be willing to challenge indicators that create a misleading impression of progress.

  • Finally, create a rhythm of strategic review. Discuss progress regularly, examine emerging evidence and adapt when circumstances change. Strategic reviews should help leaders make decisions, not simply provide an opportunity to admire the previous quarter's presentation.

These practices sound straightforward. The challenge is sustaining them when operational pressures increase and familiar habits begin to reassert themselves.

 

The leadership test

A strategy ultimately becomes real through the decisions leaders make after it has been announced.

  • Does the executive team allocate resources in accordance with its stated priorities?

  • Are managers supported when they make difficult trade-offs?

  • Are initiatives stopped when they no longer contribute to the strategy?

  • Does the CEO challenge decisions that contradict the organisation's declared direction, even when those decisions are commercially or politically convenient?

These are the moments when employees discover whether the strategy is genuinely important or simply the latest corporate initiative.

A beautifully articulated strategy can create excitement. Consistent leadership behaviour creates credibility.

 

And if the organisation is still operating in much the same way six months after the strategy was launched, perhaps the most useful next step isn't another presentation - perhaps it's a different conversation in the boardroom.

 

The Valeo Coaching Challenge

Before your next strategic review, consider three questions:

  1. What has your organisation deliberately stopped doing as a direct consequence of its current strategy?

  2. If you asked five managers to explain how the strategy should influence their next difficult decision, would you receive broadly consistent answers?

  3. If your employees were asked to identify your organisation's strategy solely by observing the decisions and behaviours of its senior leaders, would they recognise the strategy you presented to them?

 

That final question may reveal more than the entire strategic review - because the strategy your people experience is the one you actually have.

Further Reading for you…

  • Michael E. Porter (1996) - What Is Strategy?

Harvard Business Review, November–December 1996

  • Donald Sull, Rebecca Homkes and Charles Sull (2015) - Why Strategy Execution Unravels—and What to Do About It

Harvard Business Review, March 2015

  • Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton (1992) - The Balanced Scorecard: Measures That Drive Performance

Harvard Business Review, January–February 1992

 

Valeo Business Solutions Ltd — Executive coaching, leadership development and organisational performance.

 

Serious about performance. Not always serious about corporate behaviour.

 

Next
Next

The Elephant in the Boardroom Has Asked for Its Own Parking Space!